1:1 Mentorship
Strictly 1:1 Personalised Mentorship for UPSC CSE & UPPSC PCSOne dedicated mentor, only for you — no batches, no crowdLimited capacity: only a few mentorship seats open each monthA 1:1 session with your mentor every day + 24/7 chat supportMains answers evaluated live, 1:1, with spoken feedbackMentors who have personally written Mains & faced the interviewGuidance in English & HindiBook your free counselling call →

Daily Editorial Analysis 18 November 2026: Kashmir Violence and the Death Penalty Vote

18 November 2026·12 min read·Source: The Hindu editorials, 18 November 2026
GS Paper 2GS Paper 3Jammu and KashmirInternal SecurityCriminal JusticeHuman Rights

In short: The Hindu’s editorial on the Kashmir attacks argues that the fall in terrorist violence in Jammu and Kashmir should not be mistaken for peace, and calls for restoring Statehood and a political outreach alongside security operations (GS Paper 2 and 3). Its editorial on the death penalty says India’s vote against a UN moratorium is consistent with its stand, but that safeguards fail in practice, and asks for a formal suspension of executions and a review of capital offences (GS Paper 2).

Editorial 1: On the Kashmir terror attacks (security gains and the case for a political outreach)

The Hindu, 18 November 2026 · GS Paper 3: Security challenges and their management in border areas; linkages of organised crime with terrorism · GS Paper 2: Functions and responsibilities of the Union and the States

Why is it in the news?

A run of violence in the past week broke about three months of relative calm in Jammu and Kashmir. On 11 November, a terror attack on a CRPF checkpoint in Kulgam injured three jawans. Two Special Police Officers of the J&K Police were found dead with bullet wounds in Kishtwar a day after they went missing. A six-day anti-terror operation in residential areas of Kulgam followed, and on 18 November the Union Home Ministry said that Lateef Bhat, described as the last known active local terrorist of the Lashkar-e-Taiba in the Valley, had been killed in Kulgam, a day after his associate Umar Nisar.

The background in brief

PointDetails
Constitutional statusJ&K became a Union Territory with a legislature under the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019; police and public order are with the Lieutenant Governor
Elected governmentThe Omar Abdullah government took office after the 2024 Assembly elections, the first since 2014
Supreme Court, 2023In the Article 370 judgment of December 2023, the Court upheld the abrogation and recorded the Centre’s assurance that Statehood would be restored at the earliest
Security trendAccording to the police, local recruitment into terror ranks in Kashmir has fallen to single digits

What does the editorial argue?

  • The iron hand policy has worked from a strictly security point of view, since both terror attacks and local recruitment have declined.
  • The long operation in civilian areas of Kulgam has raised concerns; opposition leaders called it collective punishment that breeds alienation.
  • The police and the Army have said little about how the two SPOs were killed, and reports on the circumstances conflict.
  • The elected government is hamstrung because it has limited powers and no control over the police in the Union Territory.
  • The decline in terror incidents and the silence on the streets should not be mistaken for peace.
  • The Centre should reach out to all stakeholders, beginning with the promised restoration of Statehood, so that voters see results from their participation in the 2024 elections.
  • Political and security processes should be complementary, and the fight against Pakistan-backed terrorism should not re-open psychological wounds in Kashmir.

The other side

Position in the editorialOther positions
Long operations in residential areas cause hardshipThe Union Home Minister described the Kulgam operation as one marked by a very high level of synergy among the J&K Police, Army, CRPF and intelligence agencies, and it ended with the killing of the last known active local Lashkar terrorist (PIB, 18 Nov 2026).
Security gains need a political follow-upThe Centre’s stated position is that Statehood will be restored at an appropriate time; it has not announced a timeline, and security agencies point to Pakistan-based handlers and foreign terrorists who remain active.
Silence is not peaceReports cite security officials saying local militancy has fallen from 50-60 active local terrorists five years ago to almost none, which they see as evidence that the approach is working (Outlook India).

Why does this matter?

  • Internal security: Local recruitment has been the base of militancy in the Valley, so its decline is a real gain that must be sustained.
  • Federalism: An elected government without control of the police creates confusion over who is accountable for law and order.
  • Trust: Operations that impose hardship on whole villages can feed the alienation that militant groups exploit.
  • Democracy: High turnout in 2024 showed public faith in elections, which can weaken if elected leaders appear powerless.

Way forward

  • Announce a clear timeline for restoring Statehood, as assured before the Supreme Court.
  • Keep counter-terror pressure on cross-border networks, while following clear rules to limit hardship to civilians during operations.
  • Improve transparency on incidents such as the deaths of the SPOs, to prevent rumours and conflicting accounts.
  • Build coordination between the elected government and the security establishment through regular structured dialogue.

Conclusion: Security operations have reduced militancy, but lasting peace in Jammu and Kashmir needs a political process that gives its elected representatives real authority. The two tracks should support each other rather than compete.

Editorial 2: On India’s vote against a moratorium on the death penalty (safeguards in law and in practice)

The Hindu, 18 November 2026 · GS Paper 2: Structure, organisation and functioning of the Judiciary; Indian Constitution; issues relating to human rights

Why is it in the news?

India voted against a draft resolution at the UN General Assembly calling for a global moratorium on the use of the death penalty. India has opposed similar resolutions in earlier sessions. In its explanation of vote, India said there is no international consensus on the issue and that every state has the sovereign right to decide its own legal system and penalties.

The death penalty in India at a glance

PointDetails
Constitutional basisArticle 21 allows deprivation of life according to procedure established by law; Articles 72 and 161 give the President and Governors the power to pardon
Judicial standardBachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) upheld the penalty for the “rarest of rare” cases
ProcedureA death sentence passed by a sessions court must be confirmed by the High Court
Last executionsIn 2020, of four convicts in the 2012 Delhi gang-rape and murder case
Death row574 people on 31 December 2025, the highest since 2016 (cited in the editorial)

What does the editorial argue?

  • India’s vote is consistent with its past position, which treats the penalty as a sovereign decision backed by judicial safeguards.
  • The Supreme Court has increasingly restricted the use of capital punishment, and research has not shown that it deters crime more than life imprisonment.
  • Parliament expanded the number of capital offences in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, which the editorial calls penal populism, since poor policing and low conviction rates are what weaken deterrence.
  • The rising death row population, driven by trial court sentences, challenges the claim that safeguards work in practice.
  • Per Project 39A, the Supreme Court released 38 persons from death row in 2016-2025 after they had spent eight years there on average.
  • The penalty needs an infallibility that the system cannot supply, given flawed evidence, false testimony and unequal access to good lawyers.
  • India should suspend executions, review capital statutes and the treatment of death row prisoners, and remove the penalty for offences that do not involve intentional killing.

The other side

Position in the editorialOther positions
Safeguards fail in practiceIndia told the UN that the penalty is used only in the rarest of rare cases, with layers of appeal and the power of pardon, and that calling it state-inflicted death was a “travesty” (Outlook India).
India should join the moratoriumIndia’s position is that there is no international consensus against capital punishment and that each state may decide its own penal laws; several large countries also vote against the resolution.
Capital offences for non-fatal crimes should goSupporters of the new provisions argue that stricter punishment for crimes such as the rape of minors reflects public demand for strong deterrence and justice for victims.

Why does this matter?

  • Right to life: An irreversible penalty raises the stakes of every error in investigation or trial.
  • Access to justice: Most death row prisoners are poor and depend on legal aid, so outcomes can depend on the quality of representation.
  • Policy design: Certainty of punishment, through better policing and faster trials, deters crime more than severity alone.
  • International standing: Most countries have abolished the penalty in law or practice, which shapes how India’s rights record is seen.

Way forward

  • Commission a review of capital offences and death row conditions, building on the 2015 Law Commission report.
  • Strengthen investigation, forensic capacity and legal aid, so that convictions rest on reliable evidence.
  • Apply the Supreme Court’s sentencing guidelines, including mitigation investigation, consistently in trial courts.
  • Speed up the disposal of mercy petitions to avoid long and uncertain waits on death row.

Conclusion: India’s vote reflects a settled policy, but the gap between safeguards in law and outcomes in courts is real. Reforming investigation and trials, and reviewing the range of capital offences, would serve justice better than adding to death row.

Key Facts for Prelims

  • Jammu and Kashmir became a Union Territory with a legislature under the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019; Ladakh became a Union Territory without a legislature.
  • In December 2023, the Supreme Court upheld the abrogation of Article 370 in In Re: Article 370 of the Constitution.
  • Under Article 3, Parliament can form new States and alter the areas, boundaries or names of existing States.
  • Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) laid down the “rarest of rare” doctrine for the death penalty.
  • Article 72 gives the President, and Article 161 gives the Governor, the power to grant pardons and commute sentences.
  • The 262nd Report of the Law Commission (2015) recommended abolishing the death penalty except for terrorism and waging war.
  • The Second Optional Protocol to the ICCPR (1989) aims at abolishing the death penalty; India is not a party to it.

Practice Questions

Prelims MCQs

Q1. With reference to the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019, consider the following statements:
1. It created the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir with a legislature.
2. It created the Union Territory of Ladakh with a legislature.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  1. 1 only
  2. 2 only
  3. Both 1 and 2
  4. Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer

Answer: (a) Statement 1 is correct. Statement 2 is wrong: Ladakh is a Union Territory without a legislature.

Q2. The “rarest of rare” doctrine on the death penalty was laid down by the Supreme Court in:

  1. Jagmohan Singh v. State of U.P.
  2. Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab
  3. Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India
  4. Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India
Show answer

Answer: (b) Bachan Singh (1980) upheld the death penalty but restricted it to the rarest of rare cases; Shatrughan Chauhan (2014) dealt with delay in deciding mercy petitions.

Q3. Consider the following statements:
1. The President’s power to grant pardons is given under Article 72 of the Constitution.
2. A Governor cannot commute a death sentence under Article 161.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  1. 1 only
  2. 2 only
  3. Both 1 and 2
  4. Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer

Answer: (a) Statement 1 is correct. Statement 2 is wrong: under Article 161 a Governor can commute, remit or suspend a death sentence, although only the President can grant a full pardon for a death sentence.

Mains Practice Questions

Q. A decline in militancy is necessary but not sufficient for lasting peace in Jammu and Kashmir. Discuss the role of political processes, including the restoration of Statehood, in consolidating security gains. (15 marks, 250 words)

Approach: Introduce with the recent incidents and the decline in local recruitment. In the body, cover the 2019 reorganisation, the limits on the elected government, concerns over operations in civilian areas and the case for Statehood. Conclude on complementary political and security tracks.

Q. The safeguards around the death penalty in India are strong on paper but weak in practice. Critically examine in the light of India’s vote against the UN moratorium resolution. (15 marks, 250 words)

Approach: Introduce with the vote and India’s stated position. In the body, cover the rarest of rare doctrine, death row data, acquittals by the Supreme Court, the 2015 Law Commission report and new capital offences. Conclude on review and reform of investigation and trials.

FAQs

What were the editorials analysed on 18 November 2026?

The editorials of 18 November 2026 were The Hindu’s piece on the recent violence in Kulgam and Kishtwar and the need for a political outreach in Jammu and Kashmir, and its piece on India’s vote against a UN resolution on a moratorium on the death penalty.

Why does The Hindu want Statehood restored to Jammu and Kashmir?

The editorial argues that restoring Statehood would show voters that their large turnout in the 2024 Assembly elections gave them an elected government that can hold institutions accountable, since police and public order now lie outside its control.

What is the “rarest of rare” doctrine?

The doctrine comes from Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980), in which the Supreme Court upheld the death penalty but said it should be imposed only in the rarest of rare cases, when life imprisonment is unquestionably foreclosed.

What did the 2015 Law Commission report recommend on the death penalty?

The 262nd Report of the Law Commission, chaired by Justice A.P. Shah, recommended abolishing the death penalty for all crimes except terrorism-related offences and waging war against the State.

हिंदी सारांश

18 नवंबर 2026 के द हिंदू के पहले संपादकीय के अनुसार कुलगाम और किश्तवाड़ में हाल की हिंसा ने जम्मू-कश्मीर की तीन महीने की शांति को तोड़ा है। आतंकवादी घटनाएँ और स्थानीय भर्ती घटी हैं, पर सड़कों की ख़ामोशी को शांति नहीं समझना चाहिए। संपादकीय राज्य का दर्जा बहाल करने और सभी पक्षों से राजनीतिक संवाद की माँग करता है। दूसरे संपादकीय के अनुसार संयुक्त राष्ट्र में मृत्युदंड पर रोक के प्रस्ताव के विरुद्ध भारत का मत उसकी पुरानी नीति के अनुरूप है, पर 31 दिसंबर 2025 को 574 लोग मृत्युदंड की प्रतीक्षा में थे। संपादकीय फाँसी पर औपचारिक रोक, क़ानूनों की समीक्षा और बिना हत्या वाले अपराधों को मृत्युदंड से बाहर रखने की सलाह देता है।

Sources: The Hindu: editorial on the Kashmir terror attack (18 Nov 2026); The Hindu: editorial on India’s vote against the death penalty moratorium (18 Nov 2026); PIB: Union Home Minister on the Kulgam operation (18 Nov 2026); Outlook India: J&K down to one active local terrorist; Outlook India: India defends rarest of rare death penalty at UN.

Related reading on GSMitra: Daily Editorial Analysis 17 November 2026, Daily Editorial Analysis 16 November 2026, PIB News Today for UPSC: 18 November 2026.

Revise this topic with a custom test in the GSMitra MCQ Test Builder, or get your Mains answers on it evaluated 1:1 through GSMitra mentorship. Prefer to talk first? Book a free consultation on WhatsApp.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top